Dies to Removal

i thought I played ok this game but judging by the spec thread, I missed a lot of things.

I was honestly suspicious of iso since day 1 because it felt like he was lying to us in the mafia qt but luckily we figured it out in time

6-2 career record now :happybirthday:

Well pie wasn't lynched. Not sure if it was necessary, just might have been his reasoning

or maybe he realized that changing the claim would make him look scummy?


anyways, awesome set-up, was very fun. I had settled on voting tubehunter and went to vote him but saw that he had given himself up.

yea, I definitely misplayed when I didn't make the NK night 1....kinda blanked on my ability for a bit. I noticed soon after we made it tho, and in the end it was perhaps better since tubehunter wasn't on our team in the first place

Well that makes things easier.

Vote: Tubehunter

Alright, I've heard enough.

Unvote

Vote: Red

don't have time to iso his posts tonight. going to a hockey game tomorrow night. maybe Wednesday? I don't remember much of what red has posted...not sure if that's a point in the scum column or a point in the town column

Please claim before rereading. You have been at L-2 before and were actually lynched once as well

So I got as far in my analysis as finding the first two votes on suga... x_x

Rcw: I am almost never convinced that someone is scummy. I thought he could be but mostly it just seemed like his lynch was inevitable and the game was slowing

Looking forward to that analysis you promised, imopen.

Time to beat a dead horse! Vote Pie

Yup. Tonight? Tomorrow? Whenever I have an hour to spare I guess

I'm not sure why witchhunter was the NK (assuming it was a NK and not a vig). I guess he didnt seem scummy, but I don't remember much of what he posted yesterDay. I'll try to take a look at his posts tonight

I'm not sure what to make of it but I agree it is null. We will probably get a better idea of the scope of whatever effect protected him toMorrow.

Need to look at the sequence of events but off the top of my head I would say if suga is town then Zem is probably scum, maybe rcw. Ham is probaby scum regardless.

If suga is scum then I would need to look for bus votes, possibly you or Murphy.

However, like I said, I have to look at the sequence of votes again.

This game is dragging. It seems that most people want to lynch suga but no one is willing to hammer. I'll do it.

Vote: Suga

Let's see that flip so we can finally analyze some wagons

I'm ready to hammer Suga when everyone is ready. He is Scum guaranteed. As Iso mentioned, I had this Role in a previous game and my ability was a Day ability for balancing reasons. A Lie Detector, that can act at Night, can then lie about any information that is given to him giving there faction a huge advantage.

InflatablePie is transparent as hell. We lynch him Tomorrow.

You're waiting for our approval to vote?

The best thing we could do is to have everyone post "I am Town" and have suga choose who to investigate. I'll start (I guess CM kinda already started)

I am town

That's a really odd ability...

Iso? Murphy? Void? Can an experienced player give any insight into whether this could be a legit claim?

Hmm, somehow I missed that bit at the end of suga's post about how he was scum.

Unvote

Vote: Suga

I'm alive, just spending most of my free time arguing with my GF. It's been good times.

I felt Red was scum earlier but I don't remember why.

I'm really questioning how Pie has so many town reads when I have very few. Are we reading the same game? Some analysis would be nice also instead of just naked reads.

I'd like to see that Rez post at some point...

I thought ham was going to post more this game. I'd like to see his opinion on some of this stuff.

Night night

Hai pie

well, it's probably for the best if he wasn't going to play anymore

Am I seriously the only one that lols at a drawn out claim to be told they are a role blocker?

Idk, my role is pretty fucking weird...

Wraith, you have got to be kidding me with more flavor-gaming. If you mention flavor-gaming one more time toDay, I will vote you as a policy lynch. You aren't helping us with this shit. Understand?

I just don't think he understands the game since he insists on being ignorant to the mafiascum wiki and he seems like a generally weird dude. He has done some scummy things and I don't think he is going to be very helpful in finding scum but I'm not a fan of lynching bad town.

He needs to understand that, despite the names of the characters being public knowledge, there is absolutely no way that Stardust would make a game that could be broken based on flavor alone. That is a pointless road to go down and it is dangerous for the town.

Rcw: I feel I did answer your question. We can gain the information he provides us by way of his answers to questions he has yet answerd, for starters. Also his interactions with others should prove useful.

Do you think the fact that he is playing a different game is scum motivated? We're you suggesting a policy lynch? Please explain why his style means he should be lynched.

I need to solve how the crime occured in relation to the chractors present.

This game that you're trying to play isn't mafia

This has been evident for some time now

Hammering you is tempting but you are probably more useful for analysis later if you stay alive a bit longer.

What information would you hope to get later if you agree the game he's playing isn't Mafia?

What information do you hope to gain from lynching him before he's even responded to the questions people have posed to him? Your desperation is showing

I need to solve how the crime occured in relation to the chractors present.

This game that you're trying to play isn't mafia

This has been evident for some time now

Not sure what you mean, wraith (re: erebos), and I don't have time right now to figure it out.

If you want to convince people you are town you should start by answering the questions that iso posed to you.

Hammering you is tempting but you are probably more useful for analysis later if you stay alive a bit longer.

Wraith, where is your claim? You should probably look "mafia claim" up so you know why that means.

Red, are you scum?

Vote: Captain Murphy

For being the last to the party.

Then I will

Unvote

And

Vote: Rednihilist

You scum?