Dies to Removal

Clownfish

Wow, that went quickly! At same point in the beginning of day two, I was seriously considering casing Stardust. Not because I felt like he was scum, but because I felt like he hadn't been under any scrutiny himself, and it felt like we couldn't win if Scumdust kept flying under the radar. Then I com...

Clownfish

Stardust, it seemed like you wanted to give an estimation of who are most likely to be scumbuddies. Did I miss this, or have you held off on that for now? After casing each one in turn, I decided that trying to tie people together isn't very valuable at this time. Trying to do that too early has bu...

Clownfish

Hello all. I've caught up to the thread, read and re-read day two. Here are my thoughts: First off: rwcraspy's case of Iso. I feel like Iso has actually done a whole lot of scummy things in this game, but raspy's case is very weak. I have a number of reasons to believe Iso is town, and they are more...

Clownfish

I'd just like to post that I will be less active for a while. I'll try and keep up, but I won't have time to reread posts and closely evaluate them. I just got involved in the first (minor) political scandal I've ever had inside information on, so I suspect that will be eating up at least some of my...

Clownfish

"My current read of raspy is town, mostly because it doesn't make sense that he would be scum and not jump on the Suga wagon." This, right? Why does being scum necessarily exclude someone from being on the Suga wagon? Either I'm misunderstanding you or you're misunderstanding me. I'm sayi...

Clownfish

I'm not fishing. My problem with raising a case in this instance is that I'm genuinely not sure of what direction I want to go. While I want to help give the town direction, the issue here is that I don't want to waste my time casing a townie in the event that it turns out to be a waste of my time ...

Clownfish

Unvote I think the scumteam is among Red/Tube/Clownfish. Unfortunately, I'm not too optimistic about the town winning this one, as cases can be made on all 3 of these players, and short of some sort of confirmation through either a Tracker or a Jailer, I don't think we'll be able to PoE our options...

Clownfish

PS @ Stardust: You wrote earlier that my writing makes my posts feel off somehow. Could you expand on that or give an example? Sure. imopen2 and Iso both had minor scum reads on you, so (those being my two strongest town reads) I did my best to really read into your posts since I'd considered you m...

Clownfish

I hope to make time somewhere in the weekend to reread the entire thread in light of the Suga town flip. In short, however, referring to the list I posted on day one, the Suga flip makes me want to take another look at TubeHunter, RedNihilist and Stardust. TubeHunter and RedNihilist were both early ...

Clownfish

You must not have very much faith in your Suga read, then. :stubborn: I don't really see the purpose of faith when we will know for sure what role Suga has at the end of the day. It seems like decisions that could potentially aid mafia, like forcing Checkbox to claim, are better left off until we h...

Clownfish

Why do you still want Checkbox to claim? He could be Suga's scumbuddy. :shrug: Shouldn't we wait to see if Suga is actually scum first? What do we stand to gain from forcing Checkbox to claim before Suga's role is flipped? Do you honestly think townSuga is probable at this point? :isthatso: As I in...

Clownfish

Why do you still want Checkbox to claim? He could be Suga's scumbuddy. :shrug: :confused: Shouldn't we wait to see if Suga is actually scum first? What do we stand to gain from forcing Checkbox to claim before Suga's role is flipped? Not a lot, but he seemed to suggest at some point that there migh...

Clownfish

The best part is that ole Dusty is more than likely a scummer.

How so?

Clownfish

Thanks. A few questions: What makes you think Stardust is scumhunting well? Once DroppinSuga made his first somewhat suspicious post Stardust immediately called him out. He kept asking Suga to elucidate parts of his posts that seem scummy. It seems like a good method not to look to that confirm you...

Clownfish

Addendum to my above post: For clarity's sake, I am leaning town on Stardust and TubeHunter.

Clownfish

As far as I can see I've only had one question addressed to me while I was away, so I'll respond to that and then give some general remarks: I'm in one on-going game with Kaze (and on-going games are taboo to discuss for as long as they're on-going). Why do you ask? It was an attempt to learn how l...

Clownfish

FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU

I just accidentally a huge response post I had typed up, clarifying my reasons for the list I posted and even fixing Iso's quote tags in the process. I'm going to see if I can type it up again.

Clownfish

Awesome, your avatar really makes the thread easier to navigate, thanks :) I forgot about this: Have you read the setup information? I did. Did you mean to say that with this setup, the information we gain by night is limited? I figured that 2/6 setups have a cop. In an additional 2/6, there is a tr...

Clownfish

As far as I can see I've only had one question addressed to me while I was away, so I'll respond to that and then give some general remarks: I'm in one on-going game with Kaze (and on-going games are taboo to discuss for as long as they're on-going). Why do you ask? It was an attempt to learn how li...

Clownfish

Clownfish, the way Mafia is played here, you always want a day lynch. There's pretty much no info given out at night other than anything a PR may give. At other sites I've played, there's detailed night write ups and at those sites, a day lynch is not always useful.

Alrighty, thanks.

Clownfish

My push is based on...well, I'll let someone else try to guess before I drop the reveal on that. I can assure you that my vote is not humorous, nor is it (intentionally, if at all) based on a flawed premise. Do you seriously see nothing strange about his post? I think you misunderstood me. What I m...

Clownfish

Also, what do you mean by wagon information?

Clownfish

Clownfish, my read on Checkbox is not meta-related. It's not a quiz question, but I am in this game as an "Experienced" player, so my intention is to run you guys through the basics. Since I'm likely to carry the game on my own, I want original thought injected into the game by the newer ...

Clownfish

fuck Todd Anderson

I echo this sentiment

Clownfish

The card, like Tibalt has WAY to much variance. Apparently it's "the hotness" in control mirrors, but how many creatures are you playing in Control? A couple aetherlings? Angel of Serenity? Neither of those game ending bombs can be got after the first use of Ashiok,granted it might be har...

Clownfish

Don't ever edit posts in Mafia games. :) Double posting is ALWAYS preferred. Also, I don't recommend ever doing what I did at the start of the game because some people might consider it not in the spirit of the game. Also, Vote Checkbox . Would somebody (not Stardust) like to tell me why? :) Is tha...

Clownfish

Another question: if you want to change something about your post because you made an error, can you edit or is that a bad idea? Should you just doublepost instead? (To wit, I wanted to remove the "And" in my previous post. It's there because at first I also asked what RVS is, but I alread...

Clownfish

Haha, awesome. Pretty ballsy gambit for scum to pull, so I guess I'll forego my standard RVS vote. Ya got off easy this time, kiddo.

Vote Checkbox.

And what Gambit did Checkbox pull in your eyes?

Clownfish

Also, in a similar vein

Clownfish

for one less mana it doesn't die to mortars and has a relevant monstrous ability

Wait, what are you comparing it to? I'm guessing the dragon, but I'm not sure.

Clownfish

The gradual transparency is all fucked up

Clownfish

Hmm that also looks pretty shitty in night theme

Clownfish

I dunno if you meant it has to be in .gif format but if so

Clownfish

MMico.gif

This looks terrible in night theme.

Clownfish

/in as newbie

Clownfish

both but if you read flcl it is neigh incomprehensible

Clownfish

I hear this high school drama anime called the melancholy of haruhi suzumiya is pretty good having read it, no. like it's fine, it's entertaining in a very "wacky stuff is happening BUT THIS SUBPLOT IT'S SO DEEP (as written by a 12 year-old for an audience of 10 year-olds)" way but it's n...

Clownfish

99% of series you hear about being good are popular because 2-d goddess 3-d pig disgusting maybe you will see the underboob of a 16 year-old a few times. I guess I kind of underestimate how much the fandom's estimation of a series' quality of is driven by shallow pubescent wish-fulfillment fantasy....

Clownfish

Also I don't read manga, ever

Clownfish

I hear this high school drama anime called the melancholy of haruhi suzumiya is pretty good having read it, no. like it's fine, it's entertaining in a very "wacky stuff is happening BUT THIS SUBPLOT IT'S SO DEEP (as written by a 12 year-old for an audience of 10 year-olds)" way but it's n...

Search found 154 matches