Theros Pantheon Mafia - Game Over - Mafia Victory

[zemanjaski]

Players who need to post more:
- witch hunt
- Hamfactorial
- droppingsuga
- Tubehunter

Rednihilist can you provide me with a link to 1 Town game and 1 Mafia game that you've played here or elsewhere.

[rcwraspy]

Sorry ignore that thank - on tablet and finger slipped.

[Captain Murphy]

3.5 HOURS WOW EDGY

Care to expand on this?

Seen this posted so many times now, and I don't think it matters because the only person who posted in that 3.5 hours of L-1 who wasn't already voting him was imopen, who was already voting someone else.

You can argue people could have lurked and left, but I highly doubt it.

[Captain Murphy]

Players who need to post more:
- witch hunt
- Hamfactorial
- droppingsuga
- Tubehunter

Rednihilist can you provide me with a link to 1 Town game and 1 Mafia game that you've played here or elsewhere.

Void too

Otherwise I'm going to just push for a dropping lynch because all he has done is join popular wagons and post 0 content or hunting

[Captain Murphy]

I hope its not another game where 2 scum are just not posting and it becomes a drawn out waiting game for content

[InflatablePie]

Why would you replace in if you knew you don't have the time?

oh, I have time, just not too much.

and because I told Starbuck I would.

catching up now.

[InflatablePie]

rez town
Red town
Suga null
Witch town
Tube null
Ham null
Iso town
Void null
z town

page 1 reads that I will not be elaborating on. woo-hoo.

I kind of want to stop there tbh.

[InflatablePie]

which leaves imopen, rcw, and... Murphy.

maybe I should keep reading to get reads on them but meh they can just be our scumteam I guess

vote Murphy

[zemanjaski]

How many posts have you got on a page?

[Captain Murphy]

@Pie can you also confirm what wraith said about the role you have

[RedNihilist]

Rednihilist can you provide me with a link to 1 Town game and 1 Mafia game that you've played here or elsewhere.

TownNihilist: viewtopic.php?f=111&t=1895

Never been scum, though.

[WitchHunt]

Players who need to post more:
- witch hunt
- Hamfactorial
- droppingsuga
- Tubehunter

Rednihilist can you provide me with a link to 1 Town game and 1 Mafia game that you've played here or elsewhere.

I'm posting what I find relevant, I didn't feel like I needed to take part in the "god, you're so bad at this game Wraith" bit, I posted my thoughts on his claim and his play. Nor do I feel the need to take part in the "Man, look how buttmad so and so is" that is still going on ten pages in.

The last game I played with Red, he was quick to retaliate when pressure was put on him and it led to a pretty early wagon which labeled him as noob scum. He eventually was proven to be town if I remember correctly, so keep
that in mind with your prodding on him.

[zemanjaski]

^ that type of contribution is ideal Witch Hunt. I don't expect you to emulate my style, I just need you to post your observations because I have a pretty blunt approach; the views of more considered players are useful to compliment my style.

Besides, I do think that players who continually shirk producing useable content tend to indicate scum (eg: ham).

@ rednihilist - much appreciated, thanks.

[Stardust]

Official Votecount!

rezombad (Ephara) (1): RedNihilist
zemanjaski (Iroas) (1): rezombad
InflatablePie (Heliod) (5): TubeHunter, Iso, Void, Captain Murphy, hamfactorial (L-2)
RedNihilist (Athreos) (1): imopen2
imopen2 (Erebos) (1): rcwraspy
Captain Murphy (Karametra) (1): InflatablePie

Not voting: WitchHunt, zemanjaski, DroppinSuga

With 13 alive, it is 7 to lynch.

[rcwraspy]

rez town
Red town
Suga null
Witch town
Tube null
Ham null
Iso town
Void null
z town

page 1 reads that I will not be elaborating on. woo-hoo.

I kind of want to stop there tbh.

At L-2 it would probably behoove you to at least skim the rest of the thread. Wraith's posts put you in a hole you'll need to climb out of.

[DroppinSuga]

I will add right now that I'm not comfortable lynching WraithPie. I have to bring my son to a doctors appointment 2 hours away today so I won't be on until this evening. I will post more when I return.

[Stardust]

I have added a rule regarding the thanking of posts.

10. Thanking posts is allowed as long as you are alive in-game. Dead players and spectators may thank posts as well (so long as it won't impact the game), but must ask my permission before thanking the post.

[Stardust]

Void has been prodded.

[Iso]

oops I overslept gotta go to work now

maybe tomorrow?

[InflatablePie]

How many posts have you got on a page?

40.

@Pie can you also confirm what wraith said about the role you have

that would require me looking at what wraith said. one sec.

At L-2 it would probably behoove you to at least skim the rest of the thread. Wraith's posts put you in a hole you'll need to climb out of.

meh. I doubt I'm going to gleam anything substantial, especially if
my slot is the most suspicious one today.

[InflatablePie]

so the ISO displays backwards and oh god wraith is flavor-hunting why

[InflatablePie]

all I can think of to confirm is that Wraith claimed roleblocker for my slot.

I am also claiming roleblocker for my slot.

good god, did he not show up to the meeting about flavor-gaming, srsly.

[zemanjaski]

Thanks for trying to catch up Pie.

Still waiting from that promised post from Rezom. We should be hearing from Tubehunter soon too. I am going to try and get through Rednihilist's game in the next couple of days; if anyone else wants to chime in with their opinion of him I am listening.

[RedNihilist]

Suga promised a post as well.

[zemanjaski]

How's the fence feeling?

[RedNihilist]

Boring '-'

[zemanjaski]

What are you waiting for before posting?

[zemanjaski]

rednihilist!

[RedNihilist]

<- @office.
Seriously, you can't expect anything more than one-liners, at the moment.

Instead of pushing me you could just read my other game(s) and discover by yourself I'm town as usual.
I'd like to hear your opinion on raspy and imopen, if you've got free time.

[zemanjaski]

I've posted on raspy, ill have a re-look at imopen; it's my third game with him after all. He's more Townish than DTR mafia he was scum; that's clear to me.

[Stardust]

Void has been prodded.

And on MTGS...

[rcwraspy]

I've posted on raspy, ill have a re-look at imopen; it's my third game with him after all. He's more Townish than DTR mafia he was scum; that's clear to me.

I think this is our third game together too. You posted that I'm tricky to figure out. Why?

[zemanjaski]

Like I already said, the nature if your ridiculous role in DTR mafia has meant it's very difficult for me to have any confidence in my reads on you. You can thank Suga for that.

[rcwraspy]

Like I already said, the nature if your ridiculous role in DTR mafia has meant it's very difficult for me to have any confidence in my reads on you. You can thank Suga for that.

you all had me pegged day 1 in that game and lynched me. I just lied and spun it as a gambit due to my role, and came up with a decent towny-ish post to sell it. But you read me correctly at first.

[zemanjaski]

And knowing you we're unlynchable, it's very easy to manoeuvre us into that line of thinking. What's the pint if your last post? It seems very much like you're trying to court my suspicion.

[rcwraspy]

And knowing you we're unlynchable, it's very easy to manoeuvre us into that line of thinking. What's the pint if your last post? It seems very much like you're trying to court my suspicion.

Not trying to court anything. It just doesn't make sense to me why I'd be harder to read than somebody else, especially since I've been one of the more active posters.

[zemanjaski]

You also didn't understand our concern about Wraith's incredibly erroneous role claim so I'm not sure what to tell you. Your last few posts are aimed at clearing you, not finding scum. They don't express a Town mindset at all. I had mentioned liking your posts previously so I don't know why all of a sudden you're concerned what I think of you; you've not really attracted any heat thus far - the reasons I can think of for you taking this line are all scummy.

[zemanjaski]

We never did get those posts from Rezom or Suga either.

Is DTR lurker central or something? Did someone imperially prove that doing nothing was the optimal strategy as either faction here?

[rcwraspy]

You also didn't understand our concern about Wraith's incredibly erroneous role claim so I'm not sure what to tell you. Your last few posts are aimed at clearing you, not finding scum. They don't express a Town mindset at all. I had mentioned liking your posts previously so I don't know why all of a sudden you're concerned what I think of you; you've not really attracted any heat thus far - the reasons I can think of for you taking this line are all scummy.

It's an effort to engage you in a conversation since we're the only two people posting, and get a little more content. I don't have anybody cleared as town yet and I'd like to get at least 1 person on my conf town list before night 1.

Additionally, your comment about not
reading me just didn't sound right for how the game has evolved. Your meta shows that you develop quick reads on people - almost snap judgments - and you hammer them until they're either cleared, lynched, or you're killed somehow. Not developing a read on the person who has given arguably the most content so far seems like a pretty big fence sit for you. Why are you holding back on it?

RE: Wraith's claim. Did people not understand where I was coming from with Wraith's role claim? I obviously don't know what he was looking at, but reading the town based roleblocker in the wiki, both of his "claims" sound like they could be pointing to that. It just seemed to me like Wraith didn't realize how nit-picky role claims are and he paraphrased.

[rcwraspy]

users browsing this forum: rcwraspy, zemanjaski, and 2 guests.

Hop on in! The water's fine!