Gone Postal Mafia - Game Over - Scum Win

[Jack]

No. What are you trying to get at?

[Jack]

Io2: I'll get back to you on that. I haven't done a re-read either. By "solid case," I meant that all the evidence seemed to be there, and that there didn't seem to be an attempt to misrep.

[rezombad]

So you would be surprised if he was town; but he hasn't done anything you find scummy, just what others might find indicative of scum?

[Jack]

So you would be surprised if he was town;

I didn't say that. You said I said that.

but he hasn't done anything you find scummy, just what others might find indicative of scum?

He hasn't made a distinctly scummy move, but he hasn't given off a very townie impression either. So he's a null read who has earned a bit more of my suspicion than others.

[rezombad]

I wouldn't be surprised if red wasn't town.

Please explain the difference

[rezombad]

Take your time, I'll wait.

[imopen2]

I wouldn't be surprised if red wasn't town.

Please explain the difference

the difference is obvious. don't misrep

[rezombad]

I didn't ask you anything.

[InflatablePie]

Like I already mentioned a scum buddy mindset of wraith at a ham scum flip, the others I like to hold close to my chest

the fuck is the town motivation for this

then again, the fuck is the scum motivation for saying this (aside from not committing to reads, I get that, but it's starting to feel too obvious)

give a read on every player on the ham wagon. now. last chance.

[Cursed_Pride]

I need to reread this game.

-InflatablePie and hamfactorial are probably town.
-Still want to see DroppinSuga die.
-I understand where InflatablePie is going with Cpt. Murphy, but I have a stronger scumread on DroppinSuga.
-Everyone else is null-ish.

[Wraith223]

Back from Easter travels!

Jack, Thanks for your responses and I am satisfied as of now on you being town.

Pie is on the Hunt! CM is not responding very well either, but he always has an aggressive/sarcastic style that hurts his image. I could see a vote for him as he seems to be acting similar from last game with heavy attacks fast on me and Ham with little or no evidence, hand waving, and withholding needed scum reads.

Seems that many are not going after Rez. He has finally gone after better scum reads and is actively questioning many others. Much stronger town read, but could be forced. Still not a full towny to me. I am concerned that CM and Rez are scum buddies from the ham vote.

Still like my vote on Rez, but I will vote CM.

[imopen2]

I didn't ask you anything.

And I didn't answer the question. But I won't let you misrep people

[rezombad]

How did I misrep him? All I did was remove the double negative.

[Jack]

That altered the meaning of my sentence.

[Stardust]

Official Votecount!

hamfactorial (3): rezombad, Captain Murphy, DroppinSuga
DroppinSuga (1): Cursed_Pride,
rezombad (2): imopen2, Wraith223
Jack (1): RedNihilist
Captain Murphy (1): InflatablePie

Not voting: Jack, rcwraspy, Lord_Mcdonalds, hamfactorial

With 12 alive, it is 7 to lynch.

[rezombad]

You said you would be surprised if he was town, and also said that he hasn't done anything you found scummy, only lurking, that you said isnt distinctly scummy but others might find scummy.

[rezombad]

unvote

[rcwraspy]

@Red, do you still like your vote on Jack? Why or why not?

[RedNihilist]

Actually, I wanted to goldfish some kind of reaction by him or by some wandering knight on a white horse that wanted to defend him, but making such a move without a proper case just doesn't seem to cause the votecount to grow and leaves me without any info on the latter.
I'll think about it properly tomorrow, though, as I'm still on easterdrunkness.

[Stardust]

Lord_Mcdonalds and DroppinSuga have been prodded.

[Captain Murphy]

I don't want to and I won't pie, feel free to vote me if you want but the stew is brewing and I'm not going to be lynched for a long time with this role. I get that you are confirmed town but I already said I don't know and you can't muscle it out of me

[Captain Murphy]

Big plans ahead with my reads, not wasting it on a big lurking and meta filled day one Christ

[Captain Murphy]

What the fuck are you on about Jack?

[Captain Murphy]

I never said Rez is town, I just thought hams response to the case he put forward was stellar

[DroppinSuga]

At this point, I'm posting because I was prodded. Ham's response to Rez makes me think he's town.

unvote

I'm pretty much at a loss. I don't have one solid read.

[imopen2]

At this point, I'm posting because I was prodded. Ham's response to Rez makes me think he's town.

unvote

I'm pretty much at a loss. I don't have one solid read.

Do a reread. Look into Rez and CM especially if you would. Still haven't finished mine yet. I never seems to have time to post from somewhere other than my phone anymore

[DroppinSuga]

At this point, I'm posting because I was prodded. Ham's response to Rez makes me think he's town.

unvote

I'm pretty much at a loss. I don't have one solid read.

Do a reread. Look into Rez and CM especially if you would. Still haven't finished mine yet. I never seems to have time to post from somewhere other than my phone anymore

I'll look into CM, but Rez just seems like a townie going hardcore on a single read. I believe rez thinks he's doing the right thing, but I think he should reread and try to focus elsewhere.

Gut
reaction, CM is scum hunting, but I want to go back and read his interactions to be sure.

[imopen2]

How did I misrep him? All I did was remove the double negative.

I'm not sure how you failed to realize this changed the meaning of his statement...

[imopen2]

and why was your reaction "I didn't ask you anything," rather than listening to your fellow townie when they say you misrep'd and then looking back at your post and the post in question to see where you might have gone wrong? your reaction doesn't feel like very good team-work. it feels like an attempt to bully Jack using a rephrased statement as proof.

[rezombad]

I didn't misrep.
Don't respond to questions that aren't asked of you.

[DroppinSuga]

After a reread, I feel that CM is probably town. I don't see any real scum motivation in his posts.

[imopen2]

Can someone with more patience than me explain to Rez why he's being an idiot? I think I've wasted enough time on this

[Mcdonalds]

Oh hai, I'm still playing this

CM seems town

[InflatablePie]

unvote

Which leaves this lynch pool, FMPOV:

imopen2
DroppinSuga
RedNihilist
rcw
Lord_M

[rcw Suga Lord_M] were on the ham wagon, so it's probably best to start there. I like Suga's vote the least but his posts this page give me good vibes for some reason.

rcw did a lot of question-asking without follow-up, but I can't tell the difference between town and scum when it comes to that... I do like his post at the end of page 5 here though.

Lord_M is probably the best vote, especially considering the lurkiness.

vote Lord_M

imopen gives me slight townvibes on a reread, but that only leaves me at Red+Lord_M by PoE, which troubles me slightly.

[Wraith223]

unvote

Which leaves this lynch pool, FMPOV:

imopen2
DroppinSuga
RedNihilist
rcw
Lord_M

[rcw Suga Lord_M] were on the ham wagon, so it's probably best to start there. I like Suga's vote the least but his posts this page give me good vibes for some reason.

rcw did a lot of question-asking without follow-up, but I can't tell the difference between town and scum when it comes to that... I do like his post at the end of page 5 here though.

Lord_M is probably the best vote, especially considering the lurkiness.

vote Lord_M

imopen gives me slight townvibes on a reread, but that only leaves me at
Red+Lord_M by PoE, which troubles me slightly.

I was wondering about LMD as well, but now with his recent post...

He is lurking, but I can only think of one game I played with him, but he got replaced. He turned out scum as I recall as Red took his place. Can you be more specific on why you think LMD is scum? Is it because he thinks CM is town?

So far I still like Rez and CM (support of Rez and wagon vote) for votes (Rez for my vote).
Iamopen2 seems to be scum hunting with good points.
Jack is fairly silent and not actively scum hunting. He looks town, but just not acting like it.
Suga is still . Whatever.

So much indecision and non-scum hunting from to many players. I blame easter.

[rezombad]

vote: Jack

fos: imopen2

[imopen2]

Why the naked vote? What reason do you have to FOS me?

[rezombad]

Not a naked vote.

[imopen2]

You're not even trying.

Vote: Rez

If you're town, you are the worst town I've yet played with.

[rezombad]

You always think I'm scum though. Jack is bothering me and I'm going to continue to ask things of him until I'm satisfied.