Gone Postal Mafia - Game Over - Scum Win

[Mcdonalds]

I'm just fed up with how many sheep there are in this game. Since you are scum I can see why it isn't bothering you.

I don't see a town reason for this post.

[Cursed_Pride]

-Reread the game, apologies for inactivity - terrible couple days at work, plus unreliable internet.

I like Wrath. Newbtown, trying hard, even if I disagree with everything he's saying. Activity fell off a bit, but still my strongest town read.

After looking at his latest posts I'm cool with hamfactorial. Extremely scummy, yes, but most of his later posts come from a townie mindset. -Liked his "confirmation bias, see you all in the next game" stuff. Pending the meta research on him being a lurker, though. Also felt like he believed hunting lurkers was the right play.

Alright with Pie. He's trying to solve the game Day 1, which is good, and I think I buy his imopen2 vote rationale? Tempted to call rezombad vs hamfactorial town on town, too, but need to look at rezombad closer - hasn't really been pinging me either way.

Uhh.

Lighter town reads are rcwraspy and imopen2 - kind of like where #158
came from, and in regards to imopen, liked his townie indignation on the previous page. Felt a bit overblown, but we'll see. -Aside from those posts haven't been really paying attention.

Don't like RedNihilist. Nothing like RN I played with in Checkbox Mafia, and one of his earlier posts was very noncommital and left open a ton of escape hatches.

Don't like DroppinSuga. -Mindless, opportunistic bandwagonning, and haven't see anything from him that makes me townread him.

Hate how all of my scum reads are lurkers, and just 'existing' - I mostly have no read on the active guys, which is strange, but part of me just wants to sort them out with flips.

Fine with L_McD wagon, as again, he's just ...existing - nothing there. -I'd prefer to wagon the two more slightly scummier lurkers, but L_McD is fine for the lynch today.

Just remember to lynch those guys when I get killed N1 or something stupid like that.

[Cursed_Pride]

Mod, vote count?

[hamfactorial]

C_P:

What was Red like in your previous game? I assume he was town there, not having been in or looked through that game.

[Wraith223]

@LMD, Sorry about the false claim against you. I mistook you for CM.

Indeed, I missed Ham. Ham still is not really scum hunting. He just asks question about others, but not to the target of his suspicions. I can't tell if he is scum as the votes and pushes will tell more as the game progresses. He is null/town in my book.

Cursed_Pride, I may have been less active in the last few days, but nothing changed. If you are iterated in lurker hunting; here is the pool: LMD (posts the most of the bunch), Suga (posts and votes), Red (weakest poster, weaker standing with vote record), Jack (Votes?, posts non helpful/non-town material). If you are concerned of town tunneling (Ham v Rez, I disagree by the way) while; the strongest Lurkers are Jack and Red. The don't talk to each other and are very uninformative with reads (summarizing others instead of new theories). I could be wrong and your reads are dead on, but consider
the differentials.

[Mcdonalds]

@wraith, it's w/e

I'm gonna reread the game, Rez/imopen is my strongest scum read, I kind of think imopen/red may be scum buddies if imopen is scum but it's honestly kind of a stretch

[rezombad]

Tell me about imopen

[Mcdonalds]

Generally don't like how antagonizing he's been from the start, that and he tried to answer my question/demonstrate it was 'stupid' which doesn't sit well with me, less that he didn't like it, more that if felt like he was trying to draw attention away from nihilist.

I may be reading too much into it though (likely am)

[InflatablePie]

obvious prod dodge

been busy with prerelease, work, and other mafia games near deadlines, will try to get around to posting soon.

[rezombad]

Generally don't like how antagonizing he's been from the start, that and he tried to answer my question/demonstrate it was 'stupid' which doesn't sit well with me, less that he didn't like it, more that if felt like he was trying to draw attention away from nihilist.

I may be reading too much into it though (likely am)

What question?

[Jack]

Seems like some page 1/2 BS.

[Stardust]

Official Votecount!

hamfactorial (1): Captain Murphy
DroppinSuga (1): Cursed_Pride
rezombad (2): imopen2, Wraith223
Jack (1): RedNihilist
Lord_Mcdonalds (4): InflatablePie, hamfactorial, Jack, rezombad

Not voting: rcwraspy, Lord_Mcdonalds, DroppinSuga

With 12 alive, it is 7 to lynch.

[Stardust]

RedNihilist and imopen2 have been prodded.

Captain Murphy may need to be replaced.

Deadline is set for May 9th at 12:00 noon, CST (UTC -6). If a lynch is not achieved by that time, no lynch will occur.

[Captain Murphy]

I've had bad food poisoning and just got out of hospital today, I'm very sorry to everyone and hopefully I will feel better in the next few days stardust

[Stardust]

Sounds good, thanks for the update. Hope you're feeling better soon! That sounds bad.

[hamfactorial]

O/T: that sounds rough, CM, here's hoping you recover quickly!

Now, back to passive aggression.

[imopen2]

Alright, what're we doing today? I don't like that 2 of my main scum suspects are on the LMD wagon. Additionally, I don't even remember what LMD did that made people suspect him.

[Cursed_Pride]

@hamfactorial

Yeah, he was town. -He was also pretty darn genuine, and actually scumhunted.

@Wrath223

I'm not interested in lurker hunting, it's just that all of my current scumreads right now are lurkers. It's pretty bad since anyone can justify a lynch on him - "Oh, he's lurking! Lynch X" and we get very little information from the lynch.

Vote Lord_McDonalds

H-2.

[DroppinSuga]

What's the case on LMD?

I guess I'm missing something.

[hamfactorial]

I haven't made a case on LMD, I voted him for lurkiness after my guy told me that rez is town. Others seem to have glommed onto him as a choice after he requested replacement, but now he's back and I'm hopeful that he'll help us learn something.

[Mcdonalds]

@hamfactorial

Yeah, he was town. -He was also pretty darn genuine, and actually scumhunted.

@Wrath223

I'm not interested in lurker hunting, it's just that all of my current scumreads right now are lurkers. It's pretty bad since anyone can justify a lynch on him - "Oh, he's lurking! Lynch X" and we get very little information from the lynch.

Vote Lord_McDonalds

H-2.

nyeah,uh, isn't that why your lynching me?

Consistency much?

[imopen2]

Yea I don't get it

[RedNihilist]

I guess it's claim o'clock.

[Mcdonalds]

I'll claim when I get home but I'm now operating on the pretense that half the people on my wagon have no reason for voting me

[imopen2]

I don't think you should claim until the people on your wagon make up some more reasonable excuses for lynching you.

Lynching LMD because you're too lazy to scum hunt is piss poor. There are a lot of lurkers in this game, and some of them are asking for claims

[rezombad]

Neither of those posts are an answer to my question, LMD.

[Mcdonalds]

Explain why it took you so long to actually vote me despite thinking I'm scum since page 1

[Wraith223]

Someone at the house used most of the Gigs up on the Air cards, thus I will be limited to going to the library or somewhere with Wi-Fi for internet. Not cool. I will limited till the 8th of may. Will try to post everyday though. Back to the game...

Voting someone for being "lurky" seems viable as most scum tend to lurk in my opinion. Also, LMD is dodging most or all questions on his townlyness. After rereading the pages, he somewhat active. He votes, answers questions that aren't directed at him to bait a response, and scum hunts slightly. I don't see what cursed_pride is looking at in voting LMD? Why not Jack or Red? They literally post the least in comparason to LMD. LMD seems to be ignoring Red's question of claiming as it seems pre-mature and scum written to force the vote. He is also ignoring Cursed_Pride as his vote seems tossed against the wall to see what sticks. This bandwagon is something to watch.


unvote

VOTE RedNihilist

Rez is my primary target, but Red's question of a claim now is Bull Shit. We havn't seen a decent claim to vote him besides durpy Cursed_Pride's reason of lurking and LMD is the weakest lurker of the bunch.

[imopen2]

That was one of the best posts I've seen you make in mafia, wraith.

[rezombad]

Explain why it took you so long to actually vote me despite thinking I'm scum since page 1

explain why this isn't an answer to the question I asked you and also why this is not a claim.

[Jack]

Just as a heads up, I probably won't have time for this game aside from checking in occasionally on my phone for about a week.

I'll stand by my vote on LMD until he starts looking more town.

[Mcdonalds]

Explain why it took you so long to actually vote me despite thinking I'm scum since page 1

explain why this isn't an answer to the question I asked you and also why this is not a claim.

I asked first

[rezombad]

I asked my question two days ago. Lol.

[InflatablePie]

still town - rez, ham, me, wraith, CM, Jack, C_P

others - red, LMD, rcw, imopen, Suga

fine with voting literally anyone in that group of 3. even if I'm somehow wrong on one of rez/ham (don't think I am but still), we have a 50/50 chance lynching there.

LMD's vote on the hamwagon still bad buuuuuuut

unvote vote red

this game is incredibly boring. meh.

[InflatablePie]

*group of 5

MATH IS HARD

[hamfactorial]

It's k boss I've got the math covered.

@Pie: What about lynching Red do you find more attractive than lynching LMD?

[InflatablePie]

what about Red do I find more attractive?

~reasons~

[hamfactorial]

Ahhh, yes! Because reasons.

[rezombad]

You should totes put your vote back on LMD.

[Mcdonalds]

I asked my question two days ago. Lol.

I asked mine first

---

Imopen is ridiculous and probbscum
I like lmd for scum, and have since the first page (yeah Obama!)
Jack needs to respond to me
Pie is doing pie things.
Ham is probably fine for now.

Pedit:jack respond to things

Why weren't you voting me prior to this post then?

Generally don't like how antagonizing he's been from the start, that and he tried to answer my question/demonstrate it was 'stupid' which doesn't sit well with me, less that he didn't like it, more that if felt like he was trying to draw attention away from nihilist.

I may be reading too much into it though (likely am)

What question?